by bordonbert Fri Jun 08, 2018 6:26 am
Well done with the test. If the noise is the same with the power soak engaged or not then I think we have no choice other than swapping out a pair of valves. As the problem moves around with one of the valves it suggests that there is no problem with the TSC or biasing themselves. The problem really seems to be attached to one of the valves at least primarily.
The power amp valves are arranged in pairs and they need to be kept in those pairs. If you buy a matched quad of valves then they can go anywhere as they are all the same. Once you have used them for a while it is best to consider them as pairs and then always keep them together with their partner. If you replace only a single pair then you must either swap out the inner pair (2 + 3) or the outer pair (1 + 4) in the valve lineup of [1 - 2 - 3 - 4] meaning the pairs are [O - X - X - O].
That is why, when you kick in the power soak and reduce the power, the two inner LEDs (2 + 3) turn on showing that the inner pair has been turned off by the amp halving the power out. In general it is important for best tone and ease of working for other components to keep the valves driving the two opposite sides of the output transformer supplying equal DC current when idling and equal signal voltage when driven. That way the DC currents cancel out exactly which we want and the two sides of the signal are kept as equal at the speaker as they are from the guitar.
Once your amp is stable and working it isn't a bad idea to mark them on the glass envelope with a permanent felt tip pen for identification. There is a load of horsefeathers on the internet about how this is a bad thing to do, it isn't. Valves are not the same as halogen bulbs! They are in a plain old hard glass tube and the ink will have no damaging effect on that at all. I wouldn't want to cover them in fish and chip grease of course, so they are best kept cleanish but a little dirt, dust or ink won't compromise them. I would use a system such as numbering them as a pair and as an individual kind of "pair num . valve num". So 1.1 and 1.2 would be for pair 1, valves 1 and 2 say in the outer slots. The others in the inner slots would be 2.1 and 2.2 of course. A new pair would come in as 3.1 + 3.2 and be kept together. That means that in either pair the first number should always be the same. It's only to be able to identify them individually and to keep them together as pairs. If you just number them 1, 2, 3, 4 you will be surprised how easily you can forget which went with which once they move around a couple of times. That would mean that the numbered valves would look like [1.1 - 2.1 - 2.2 - 1.2] when they are fitted in the amp.
You need to swap out your damaged valve with the extra TSC flashes and the one that partnered it which would originally have been the left hand outside when it was on the right outside. Assuming you have swapped both of them to the inside to test it would mean both inner valves. I will say try to keep it like that but this isn't too important in your case as the three remaining valves all show the same current via the TSC setup so they are still effectively balanced whichever pair you choose to keep. Also, keep the third valve for a spare as it still looks good, you never know when it may be useful.