bordonbert wrote:Are you saying that, if Steve Vai was playing a no-name Strat direct through a no-name amp and cab you would not like his sound? For me, at the end of the day the guitarists I love sound incredible no matter what their setup is when I hear them. It may be slightly different to what I am used to but that is of no consequence. Yes, they would choose great gear and make sure to get the sound they want in general, but that doesn't mean I am not thrilled at what I hear when I see them with run of the mill kit. I've seen someone I suspect you may like, Guthrie Govan, get up and jam in a local pub with borrowed gear and he is still amazing, with the ability to coax astounding tone out of that unfamiliar gear. That's a great guitarist with the tone in his fingers.
I want and expect the direct sound of one or more guitar 4x12 cabinets to be hitting me in the face. To me, that is the definition for Rock and Roll.
In fact Al Dimeola has that problem. His sound comes from the PA and not from stage amps. While his tone was great, I'm sitting up front and his sound is coming from the side PA speakers. It emotionally detached me from his guitar playing and I ended up walking to the back of the hall to hear the guitar sync up with the performance I was seeing.